Whilst it might not be a household name, Halma (LSE:HLMA) is a UK share that has become a model of consistency when it comes to delivering shareholder value.

For the last 19 years, Halma’s management team have consistently delivered record profits in each successive year. And if that wasn’t enough to catch my attention, then the fact that for 43 years in a row Halma has continued to increase its dividend payments by more than 5% is even more impressive.

Over the last 10 years, the FTSE 100 index has delivered total shareholders returns of 91%. However, over the same period Halma has delivered an impressive total shareholder return of 655%.  It is an exemplar of consistent and reliable value generation that Warren Buffett, the great Sage of Omaha, would be proud of.

Having reviewed the upside, now let me explore what the market thinks of Halma. Surprisingly, given its previous track record, it is not such a positive outlook, with the shares having lost almost 30% of their value in the year to date. Having ended 2021 on a high of 3,200p per share, they have since had a rough-and-tumble journey into 2022, having bottomed out at 1,876p in June, before recovering some ground in recent times to 2,289p. 

So has the market overreacted in its recent re-rating of Halma? Does this in turn present me with an opportunity to buy an undervalued stock, or does the current market price offer a fair and equitable reflection of the value presented by Halma shares?

To be honest, my investment analysis of Halma isn’t compelling either way. On one hand, Halma’s performance over the years has been the model of consistency on which investors can genuinely rely. On the other hand, however, it feels like that consistency and reliability of delivering shareholder returns has already been baked into the current share price. 

Whilst Halma has delivered remarkable returns over decades, as a prospective investor today I am being asked to pay a high price for such consistent performance, which is amplified by the current price-to-earnings ratio of 35. As an investor who is trying to uncover value opportunities, I feel like these shares are already trading at a high premium and don’t therefore offer the margin of safety that I normally look for in an investment.  

When assessing the opportunity to own part of a company that for decades has continuously demonstrated the ability to deliver consistent and reliable returns of shareholder value, my heart is willing me to invest. But I know from bitter experience that when I make investment decisions based on emotion, they very rarely work out for me.

So, for the moment my investing brain is going to overrule my heart and instead focus on investment fundamentals, which indicate that the current Halma share price is one that I am simply unwilling to pay.

More reading

Robert Cooley has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Halma. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

However, for those investors in UK retail powerhouse JD Sports Fashion (LSE:JD), it has felt like they were in a race to the bottom, with its share price falling by over 50% from its November 2021 peak of 234p to a sobering 103p last month.

JD Sports has been a consistently outstanding performer in the retail sector over the last 10 years, so what has caused the collapse in its share price over the last nine months?

Take a quick search through the news and you will not have to look far before you see stories about JD Sports’ acquisition of its competitor Footasylum in 2019 for £90m, which has since been the subject of a Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) investigation into corporate governance practices.   

As a result of the CMA investigation, JD Sports was instructed to sell Footasylum in November 2021, which triggered the freefall in the company’s share price.  This was followed in February 2022, by the CMA fining both JD Sports and Footasylum £5m each, after its investigation concluded that the chairmen of both companies “exchanged commercially sensitive information”.  

Finally, following its own internal governance review, JD Sports announced in May that its long-standing chairman Peter Cowgill would be standing down with immediate effect.  Earlier this month Andrew Higginson, the former chairman of Morrisons, became the new chairman of JD Sports, charged with returning the company to its former glory.

Whilst the Footasylum saga and the resulting CMA investigation and fines have clearly damaged market sentiment towards JD Sports in recent times, I am keen to understand how the company has actually performed as a business during these testing times and whether it has been accurately reflected by the falling share price.

JD Sports has had a chastening few years of negative headlines relating to corporate governance shortfalls under the previous regime, resulting in market support for the company being hard to find.  However, behind the headlines, JD Sports has continued to focus on what it is good at, which is working with high-end sport fashion brands to deliver exactly what their customers want.    

Last month JD Sports finally released its full year results, delayed from February, and it has to be said that the results were welcome news for its shareholders. Against the previous year’s business performance, JD Sports’ revenue increased by 40%, profits doubled and the number of stores across the group increased by over 25%. 

The market has not been slow to react to the recent JD Sports results, lifting its share price by 30% since they were published a month ago. Although battered and bruised over the last 12 months, JD Sports has continued to do what it does best by continuing to deliver outstanding business performance, but it is doing it now with a heavily discounted share price. 

JD Sports looks like a FTSE 100 star that is priced too cheaply, so I have added it to my watch list.      

More reading

Robert Cooley has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

Over the 25-year period from June 1993 until November 2018, the average annual dividend returned by FTSE 100 companies was 3.47%.

As an investor seeking to mitigate the impact of increasing inflation, an investment in a high-dividend-yield mining company like BHP Group (LSE:BHP) may provide me with a degree of comfort and protection.

Globally, there has been a strong and consistent demand for metals and commodities, particularly from an energy sector pivoting towards investment and development in renewable technologies. This demand has resulted in the spot price of copper more than doubling from March 2020 ($2.13lb) to hit its peak in March 2022 ($4.69lb), although it has receded in recent weeks by over 20% to serve as a gentle reminder of the volatility of commodities.

Unsurprisingly, the share price of BHP has trodden a similar path to the copper prices since March 2020, where it started its meteoric ascent from 1,054p to a lofty peak of 3,019p in late March 2022. With such tight correlation to the price of copper, however, it should come as no surprise to see BHP lose similar ground in recent weeks with its share price also receding by approximately 20%.

Mining stocks have historically been viewed as cyclical, with the traditional wisdom being that demand for raw materials and commodities falls during recessionary periods, dragging down mining share prices with them. So, with the UK teetering on the edge of a recession, it is worth considering whether BHP still presents an attractive case for investment.

Well, the current dividend speaks for itself, with BHP delivering a mouth-watering 11.5% yield. However, since I seek capital growth as well as sky-high dividends, the investment appraisal is not straightforward. 

Volatility in the commodities market, in particular copper, continues to drive volatility in share prices in the mining sector. BHP stands out from the mining crowd, however, in its efforts to diversify its portfolio through exposure to the potash market, which could provide me with mitigation against market volatility whilst also providing the opportunity for significant returns on my investments in the future.

Potash is a potassium-rich crop fertiliser. Previously, 40% of all supplies of potash originated from Russia and Belarus; however, this supply has now been choked as a result of economic sanctions in response to the Ukrainian conflict. 

Over the last five years, potash prices have bumbled along between $200-$250 per tonne, but as soon as Russian soldiers set foot in Ukraine, that price rocketed to $562 per tonne, where it has stayed ever since. Irrespective of how the current Ukrainian conflict plays out, there is little doubt that the Western economies will continue to reduce their reliance on the supply of Russian commodities.

In response, BHP is already reshaping its portfolio of projects by seeking to capitalise on the demand for potash by recently approving a £5.6bn investment in the Jansen Stage 1 project in Canada that will be capable of delivering 4.35 million tonnes of potash per year from 2027 onwards.  

Whilst the current BHP dividend yield of 11.5% is hard to ignore, the seeds of the recent Jansen Stage 1 investment are not due to bear fruit for another five years, so this cautious investor plans to sit and wait until I can see some green shoots of growth from BHP’s potash strategy!

More reading

Scott Cooley has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned.  Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.